Skip to main content

The Magic Money Tree and the Tories. #Corbyn4PM #EconomyunsafewithTories. Richard Murphy

Richard Murphy  This is an attributed reblogging of the beginning of two very important analysis carried out by Richard Murphy. The analytic chickens of the screeching Tory´s are coming home to roost. 

Richard MurphyRead more about me



POSTED ON MARCH 13 2016


I was interviewed twice on the radio on Friday evening to discuss John McDonnell’s new fiscal rule, once on LBC and the other on Radio 5. In both cases the interviewers were quite explicit in stating that it was known that Labour always borrowed more than the Conservatives and that was why the electorate could not trust them with the economy. I knew that evidence I had prepared a year ago did not support that view in recent years (post 1997) but I decided to see if this claim really had any substance to it all at all. This blog is about my findings. There is a note on data sources at the end.
The first task was to secure data on borrowing by year from 1946/47 onwards: this data covers a 70 year period. Labour was in office for 28 of these years and the Conservatives for 42.
The next task was very simple: I  calculated the total net borrowing in Labour and Conservative years and averaged them by the number of years in office. All figures are stated billions of pounds in all the tables that follow and in this case are in original values i.e. in the prices of the periods when they actually occurred:
Screen Shot 2016-03-12 at 20.22.49
The Conservatives borrowed more, not just absolutely (which is unsurprising as they had more years in office), but on average.
This though, is a bit unfair: the value of money changes over time. So I restated all borrowing in 2014 prices to eliminate the bias this gives rise to. This resulted in the following table:
Screen Shot 2016-03-12 at 20.28.21
In current prices the Conservatives still borrowed more (much more) overall, and on average, by a long way.
Creative Commons License
Tax Research UK Blog by Richard Murphy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.

There is a magic money tree, so why did politicians lie about it throughout 2016?


POSTED ON DECEMBER 22 2016


One of the most common claims of recent years is that ‘there is no magic money tree’. David Cameron did it:
He claimed to tell a plain truth that there was no magic money tree. He said those who thought there was put at risk the whole future of the economy.
But David Cameron lied about this. As the Telegraph has said:
The well repeated line that “there is no such thing as a magic money tree” is heard almost everywhere. Even Prime Minister David Cameron has uttered this phrase.
But it’s completely untrue. If the will exists, the central bank can issue unlimited amounts of currency.
screen-shot-2016-12-22-at-07-03-51
Creative Commons License
Tax Research UK Blog by Richard Murphy is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.


THERESA MAY AND THE CAUSES OF THE 2008 CRASH. #THEAUSTERITYLIE #THEBANKERSCRASHOF2008






http://positivemoney.org/issues/recessions-crisis/

“The financial crisis of 2007 to 2008 occurred because we failed to constrain the
financial system’s creation of private credit and money.”



http://letthemconfectsweeterlies.blogspot.se/2011/05/one-good-cut.html

For some reason, this video is no longer publicly listed on the PM website? (See Memory Hole series of posts.

http://letthemconfectsweeterlies.blogspot.se/2017/04/economists-apologists-and-sophists-for.html


Popular posts from this blog

Syria Cui Bono, Incitatus (Boris Johnson) Caligula (john Kerry) and the Curious case of the New Consul at the United Nations Security Council (Updated 7th April , Trump ordered attack On Syria)

UPDATE FOR CONTEXT:

Roger Lewis7 April 2017 at 12:56 Syria is all about Gas, not poison Sarin Gas but Gas Pipelines. It is also not about Hydro Carbons in themselves but the market for hydrocarbons and which currency contracts of supply are settled in otherwise known  as,  US petrodollar hegemony.
https://letthemconfectsweeterlies.blogspot.se/2017/04/sand-box-for-carbon-based-currency-end.html
Legitimate question. Does Jared Kushner have any interests in the Leviathan Gas field or any of the Israeli-backed Pipeline projects? #MAGA#Drain The Swamp. Starting to dig around will report back.

https://letthemconfectsweeterlies.blogspot.se/2017/04/the-bortherhood-of-gas-ring-quatar-gas.html


THE BROTHERHOOD OF THE GAS RING. QATARI GAS, OR SAUDI HEGENOMY, TRUMP BACKS THE SAUDIS? TANGLED WEB INDEED Tangled Web,  Syria and Gas. Trump meets Egyptian President, that is a rejection of the Moslem Brotherhood, siding against Qatar in Syria and With Saudi broadly and therefore the ISIL Wahabbist and Saud…

Meet The Fuggers, Brexit, The Euro and Clueless Elites.

Meet the Fuggers or, its the Money Power stupid. Brexit, The Euro and clueless Elites.



The Eastern Roman empire under Justinian saw the seeds of its final fall to The Ottomans when Abd El Melik started paying tribute in Gold coinage under his own Political Branding you might say.

With all the talk of Brexit being the removal of a final obstacle to the deeper federation of a European State transcending tiresome nationalism, perhaps a little review of History, particularly Monetary history, might not be such a bad thing.

In the review of European competences carried out as a consultation by the foreign office regarding Brexit and or reform requirements of the Eu, two of the papers need to be considered in the context of the Money power argument.

The first paper considered is the Subsidiarity and proportionality aspects of the Lisbon treaty and the competences of the EU institutions vis National and regional democratic institutions. This is a trade-off between Centralised Efficiency and …

Cashless Society, BlockChain, Global Warming, Gold, Carbon . Geo Political Full House.

rogerglewis9:02 am on October 26, 2017Permalink | Reply | Edit | FollowIMF Head on Climate: “we will be toasted, roasted and grilled”  Roger Lewis October 26, 2017 at 7:57 am #
https://wattsupwiththat.com/2017/10/25/imf-head-on-climate-we-will-be-toasted-roasted-and-grilled/comment-page-1/#comment-2646454 Legarde pushing the AGW Global Warming Narrative reported on Watts Up With That today. Upticks in CLimate Stories and developments on the Petro Dollar are quite common.
I am certain that the two things are not unrelated. rogerglewis Your comment is awaiting moderation.
October 25, 2017 at 11:51 pm
Things are really hotting up on the Future Prospects of the Petro Dollar. Climate Change particularly the AGW CO2 Narrative is clung to with religious zeal and promoted by Finance Elites, why is that?
China are rolling out the Petro Yuan, backed by gold.
http://www.golemxiv.co.uk/2017/10/chinas-rise-americas-fall/ The IMF wish to cling to the Petro Dollar hegemon this is best done by having t…